Cause for celebration? Or cause for concern…?
On the same day the Order was announced, DNR also released preliminary maps of the 77,000 acres through their newly launched “structurally complex forest finder.” This model identifies more than 77,000 acres, which means that some of these structurally complex forests would be available for logging, including some of the sales that had been previously paused for fiscal year 2026 and beyond (more on this soon…).
The preliminary selection was far from ideal, and contained major errors, many of which were identified by the Legacy Forest Defense Coalition (LFDC), who did a thorough review of the mapping issues and implications - all of which alarmed the conservation community. The selection of acreage in the preliminary DNR maps seemed to contradict the supposed intent of the executive order: to conserve 77,000 acres of mature, structurally complex forests. In addition to multiple mapping errors, a significant amount of acreage consisted of slivers of land less than 5 acres that will not serve as meaningful older forest habitat. Many conservation community members felt very concerned about these maps not reflecting the spirit of the executive order.
Through several intense meetings between members of the larger legacy forest movement and Commissioner Upthegrove and DNR staff, Upthegrove pledged to work collaboratively to correct the mapping problems and errors. Commissioner Upthegrove made it very clear that the maps are preliminary.
CRF would also like to note that having these maps available to the public for feedback is a positive step toward better data transparency.
Commissioner Upthegrove also addressed a major concern about the DNR’s five year timber sale plan. Previously put on hold during DNR’s “Time out for Trees,” the timber sales containing structurally complex forests scheduled for the next five years were not included in the 77,000 acres, which made it seem that DNR was proceeding with all of these sales. Commissioner Upthegrove made it clear that this will likely not be the case once the maps are redrawn, but that acres in excess of 77,000 still may be logged. We anticipate seeing some of the sales containing legacy forests scheduled for Fiscal Year 2026 to move forward due to the significant costs already invested in the planning process. However, we are optimistic that the final map will correct this significant error of including all legacy forest sales scheduled for the next five years.
CRF is now laser focused on advocating for the DNR to adopt the best possible criteria for making the ultimate selection of the 77,000 acres as strong as possible. We are rolling up our sleeves and working on influencing the next iteration of the map of conservation acres, working towards a map that we can support as an organization dedicated to the permanent conservation of legacy forest on our state public lands.
Legislative action will be needed…
Another significant part of the Order will involve requesting legislative authority and support to generate alternative revenue other than from logging. As quoted from the DNR’s “Forest Forward” flyer passed out at the press conference,
“Leveraging DNR’s globally recognized leadership in sustainable land management, we will pursue strategies other than traditional industrial harvests to ensure these carbon-dense, habitat-rich forests are available for future generations.”
Proposed Forest-Forward Strategies:
-
Enter Carbon Markets
-
Pursue Additional Ecosystem Services
-
Promote Mass TImber Markets
-
Acquire Additional Forests
-
Maximize Returns on Certified Forest Products
The Commissioner said he will be asking the legislature to pass a bill giving DNR clear authority to directly enter the ecosystem service markets.
We are expecting timber industry opposition, and we will need your help in the next Legislative Session to make progress! When Big Timber interests begin their attack, we will also need your help to show widespread public support for conserving legacy forests. We expect this to heat up in the following months, so please keep your eye out for future action alerts from us!
Moving Forward:
Assuming the Commissioner approves a significantly better selection of 77,000 acres, we see Commissioner Upthegrove’s Order as a major first step in shifting how we steward our state forests—moving toward an approach that prioritizes long-term ecological health. If well-designed, it can also help DNR meet its Habitat Conservation Plan (HCP) goals for older forests far more quickly than under previous strategies.
From its inception, CRF’s mission has been to achieve the permanent protection of the last remaining legacy forests in Western Washington. These irreplaceable forests aren’t just dollar signs to be harvested for profit — they’re critical for:
-
Endangered species habit
-
Watershed health
-
Salmon recovery
-
Indigenous cultural resources
-
Sources of clean water
-
Natural flood and drought mitigation
-
Wildfire & pest resilience.
These mature, structurally complex forests are our best natural climate solution - the old growth of the future!!
The repetitive disinformation dolled out by Big Timber marketing and industry-funded ”research” cannot undermine the ecological reality of our forested ecosystem. We do not have to abide by the false choice of clearcut logging versus ecological forestry. We do not have to perpetuate the false choice of aggressive industrial logging versus funding schools and important county services. The scientific community has shown that there are ways to manage forests ecologically BOTH for timber harvest AND for ecological integrity.
Commissioner Upthegrove’s order to protect 77,000 acres of legacy forests helps take us one step closer to breaking free from the prison of false choices, and aligns with:
-
Legal authority: In 2022, the State Supreme Court unanimously ruled in the Conservation NW et al. v. Franz case that DNR’s mandate includes benefiting both trust beneficiaries and the public: WA’s forests can be managed for multiple benefits, not solely for maximizing timber revenue. Commissioner Upthegrove’s order is the first major action that puts DNR’s newly affirmed broad discretion into action.
-
Legislative action: Over the past three years, Washington’s legislature has allocated around $120 million under the Climate Commitment Act to acquire replacement forestlands in exchange for conserving these carbon-rich legacy forests because of their significant climate benefits.
This is a shift toward a bigger vision—one where we rethink forestry and create new ways for rural communities to thrive. There is room to find win-win solutions. The pushback from the timber industry has already begun. The American Forest Resource Council issued a press release on the day of the announcement roundly criticizing any move to conserve older forests. They also are threatening a legal challenge.
We need to consistently reinforce the new legal precedent: under the CNW vs. Franz ruling, DNR has broad discretion to manage public lands for myriad benefits—not just maximum timber revenue.
And let’s face reality: the current funding system is outdated. Some rural communities and DNR itself still depend heavily on timber revenue generated through industrial clear-cut practices. This needs to change. CRF will be working closely with the DNR and state lawmakers to develop alternative funding sources for rural communities and to expand ecological forest management across the state.
Support the Movement:
Please support CRF’s mission by donating today. Your generosity powers everything we do. Right now is a critical moment for CRF to continue our work.
As we work with DNR to refine the preliminary maps and outline the best possible criteria, CRF will be in these forests ground-truthing these areas to verify the next iteration of maps. For example, we need to raise $500 for a new camera and for gas money to send our experienced team of surveyors out in the woods this week!
We need your support to continue our on-the-ground survey work. We also need your support to continue our legislative and policy work to develop alternative funding sources for rural communities and to expand ecological forest management.
With your help, together we can shape a forest future rooted in science, justice, and care for generations to come.